The psychological mechanisms that protect unreasonable. Wagner session i chapters 1 3, pages 3 21 questions what thoughts flow through your mind when you reflect on the words shema yisrael hashem elokaynu hashem echad. Lamm argues that the passage in question should be compared to mt, hilkhot talmud torah 1. Norman lamm, former president of yeshiva university and current chancellor is identified with modern orthodox judaism but his volume is addressed to a wider audience to believing people of all faiths, students of religion, to the searchers and curious and even to the skeptics and. Jesus the pharisee a new look at the jewishness of jesus, harvey falk, 1985, religion, 175 pages. Doubt, a parable is inspired partially by the child sexual abuse scandal in the roman catholic church which was perpetrated by a small number of priests and often covered up for years by certain members of that churchs hierarchy. Rabbi norman lamm, former chancellor of yeshiva university, has also written on this subject, asserting that if the existence of extraterrestrial life should be confirmed, religious scholars must revise previous assumptions to the contrary. Does maimonidess mishneh torah forbid reading the guide. Nonetheless, in an updated version of his own article, published as the unity theme. Doubt can drive us to seek truth or it can drown us in despair, hopelessness, and confusion. Torah is a torah of truth, and to hide from the facts is to distort that truth into mythit is this kind of position which honest men, particularly honest believers in god and torah, must adopt at all times, and especially. Sep 29, 2006 a torah scroll from the lodz ghetto that was saved during the holocaust was presented to norman lamm and moshe tendler, president and talmud teacher, respectively, at yeshiva university, on behalf of the school.
When you are in the middle of doubting, it is critical to experience the love, grace, and guid ance of the body of christ. Adam ki yakriv mikem korbonlashem, when any man of you bringeth an offering unto the lordr the zohar, intrigued by the use of the term adam, declares that by this word. Rabbi lamm is chancellor and former president of yeshiva university. Norman lamm prior to and during his years as president of yeshiva university. We use this doubt to excuse many of our transgressions, and we excuse the existence of this doubt by saying that had we lived in the age of the prophets or the age of miracles or the age of revelation, we would be sufficiently. Torah is a torah of truth, and to hide from the facts is to distort that truth into myth. In one of his books, norman lamm treats wiesels theological novel, the town beyond the wall, to literary, theological and judaic commentary. Norman lamm wrote a book faith and doubt which argued for the positive view of having doubt and having searching questions. Norman lamm, president emeritus of yeshiva university, would proudly tell us how during his long tenure as head of yeshiva, not one student switched from riets to the conservative movements jewish theological seminary. Thus the central portion of the haggadah explains each of the major symbols. Norman lamm the religious implications of extraterrestrial life, chapter 5 of faith and doubt studies in traditional jewish thought, new york, ktav, 1971.
Lamm offers six models for the relationship between torah and general wisdom. Nature in the sources of judaism american academy of. Wolpes three suggestions derived from bemidbar are reminiscent to my mind of three recommendations made by r. Jewish center march 18,1967 the man in the middle the.
Answers to tough questions about doubt, a parable the. And yaakov was greatly afraid, and he was distressed and yaakov said. Norman lamm born december 19, 1927 is an american modern orthodox rabbi, scholar, author and jewish communal leader. Some factors are considered valid, even encouraged, yet others are derided. Spirituality and law in judaism logos bible software. Doubt available for download and read online in other formats. I read his book fall to grace in 2011 and found it to be refreshingly honest and forthright. When thou shalt besiege a city a long time, in making war against it to take it, thou shalt not destroy the trees thereof by wielding an ax against them. God of my father avraham and god of my father yitzhak. Originally published in religious studies 9 1973, pp. Themes range from comparative law to metaphysics with a chapter on law and. Riecken, and stanley schachter, when prophecy fails. How, in the encounter of halakhic judaism with modern thought, can we preserve both our integrity and our.
Wagner session i chapters 1 3, pages 3 21 questions what thoughts flow through your mind when you reflect on the words shema yisrael. Just over a month ago, at the luncheon following ezras wonderful bar mitzvah here at har shalom, i ran into my second cousin who came in from new jersey to celebrate with us. It can drive us to seek truth or it can drown us in despair, hopelessness, and. Publication date 1986 topics orthodox judaism publisher new york. Aug 03, 2001 the faith and doubt of holocaust survivors by reeve robert brenner faith and doubt. The novels protagonists symbolically proceed through a range of theological views, which wiesels midrashic style literature can explore where theodicy fails. Norman lamm chancellor and rosh hayeshiva, yeshiva university this article was originally delivered by rabbi lamm as a derasha in the jewish center in nyc on rosh hashana in 1961. The problem to which this paper is addressed is of momentous importance. But it can also deepen your relationship with god as you seek satisfying answers to lifes mysteries.
These lectures were recorded at a variety of venues, including alumni gatherings, dorm talks, chag hasemikhah ceremonies, memorial occasions, and more. Faith and doubt the first, that of acknowledgment, is a cognitive type of faith, in which i intellectually accept certain propositions as true such as the existence and unity of god whether or not i can offer convincing logical proof for my conviction. Rabbi norman lamm shavuot ii the jewish center june 15, 1967 0 jerusalem. Criticalhistorical study of jewish mystical texts began in 19th century, but gershom scholems school in the mid20th century founded the methodological disciple in academia, returning mysticism to a central position in jewish historiography and jewish studies departments. Norman lamm the former chancellor of yeshiva university gave these factors definition. Faith and doubt addresses the question of the encounter of religious faith with modern life and civilization. A philosophical and spiritual look at sacred time and shabbat. He was the chancellor of yeshiva university until he announced his retirement on july 1, 20 he holds a ph. Norman lamm ktav, third augmented edition, 2006 who is the author. The presence of faith does not mean the absence of doubt.
Although lamm identified all the pertinent elements of a jewish perspective. For more on bal tashchit of energy and an explanation of this source. Jewish education at the lookstein center faith and doubt. Summoning the will not to waste jewish eco seminars. Study guide to the shema, by norman lamm prepared by rabbi dr. The man of today and the jewish bible, israel and the world. Written from ortbergs own struggle with faith and doubt, this book will challenge. Norman lamm chancellor and rosh hayeshiva, yeshiva university this article was originally delivered by rabbi lamm as a derasha in the jewish center in nyc on rosh hashana in 1961 one of the fascinating minor themes in our. Norman lamm has set the tone for this mode of inquiry. Jan 01, 20 jay bakker continues his faith journey with his new book, faith, doubt, and other lines ive crossed.
The act, then, does indeed issue from the matrix of polarities in tension, but it itself must be expressive of only one or the other. Cohen, norman lamm, apr 1, 1986, religion, 330 pages. Jewish center march 18,1967 the man in the middle the key verse in our sidra, which introduces the entire subject of sacrifices, reads. This commitment demands of me that, by my practice, i slice through the polarity of faith and doubt and opt for one or the other. Lamm describes god as beyond personality, which is to say that, in accord with kabbalah, he has both an impersonal aspect, the ein sof. Sinai, because this festival commemorates the revelation of the torah on mount sinai. He served for one year as assistant to rabbi joseph lookstein and thereafter as rabbi of congregation kodimoh in springfield, massachusetts, and. A mysterious encounter with god brought him to recognition of a realm that lay beyond his comprehension.
The moving wall represents the time period between the last issue available in jstor and the most recently published issue of a journal. The biblical norm which most directly addresses itself to the ecological situation is that known as bal taschit, thou shalt not destroy. Studies in traditional jewish thought by norman lamm the drowned and the saved by primo levi. The faith and doubt of holocaust survivors by reeve robert brenner faith and doubt. For christians, doubt can either serve us or sink us. The shema is the central prayer of the jewish faith. Sermons of rabbi norman lamm rabbi norman lamm received semicha from the rabbi isaac elchanan theological seminary in 1951 and his phd from the bernard revel graduate school of jewish studies in 1966. Jews utter this single sentence, affirming gods unity as their final words before dying, as well as at the beginning and ending of each day. It is this kind of position which honest men, particularly honest believers in god and torah, must adopt at all times, and especially in our times. Doubt becomes not an impediment, but a goad to reinvestigate and deepen cognitive faith assertions. As bobby points out multiple times, be sure to share your doubts with others.
Ordained by rabbi yosef dov soloveitchik and armed with a. Communities of faith face crises from time to time. Spurious doubt refers to a cynical type of questioning that does not arise from a. A social and psychological study of a modern group that predicted the destruction of the world new york. Because of previous pain or disappointment, cynics make their conclusions about life before the questions have even been asked. For centuries, jews have pronounced this single sentence affirming gods unity as their final words before dying, as well as beginning and ending each day with this prayer on their lips.
When bad things happen to good people, harold kushner. In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a zero moving wall, so their current issues are available. The opening episode of last weeks parashah introduced us to a changed yaakov. Yeshiva university a togo series tishrei 5772 let there be light rabbi dr. He, too, does not rule out this possibility from an. Using the shema as his focus, lamm, prominent orthodox scholar and longtime president of yeshiva university, explores the relationship between spirituality and law in judaism. If ignored or left unchecked, it can bore into our brain.
Pesah, matzah, and maror rabbi norman lamm chancellor and rosh hayeshiva, yeshiva university the whole of the seder shows the development from the impersonal to the personal, from the historical to the biographical, from recounting to reliving. Yaakov woke up from his dream afraid, and immediately recognized the inexplicable awesomeness of his resting place. However tucked away in a footnote 52 he presents a similar position to the above noting hilchos avoda zara 2. Modern orthodoxy often perceives itself and is perceived by others as a movement which grants more importance to moral considerations in its interpretation of halakha and in its general worldview than does the ultraorthodox movement. Fundamentalism and the fear of truth oxford university press, 2008. Hashanah for two days, because of the doubt involved. He offers a vivid, historical tour of our willingness to suspend reason in favor of religious beliefs even when these beliefs inspire the worst of human atrocities. Presents a collection of studies on modern intellectual challenges from the perspective of modern orthodox judaism. In the 1950s, a plurality of jts students were yeshiva college graduates. Norman lamm the shema has been described as the central watchword of jewish faith. Norman lamms trailblazing talmudic methodology the. The lamm lectures audio collection consists of lectures, speeches, and shiurim delivered by rabbi dr. Three localities play roles of importance in the festival of shavuot. Nature in the sources of judaism american academy of arts.
Themes range from comparative law to metaphysics with a chapter on law and morality new to this edition. O save me from the hand of my brother, from the hand of esav, for i fear him, lest he come and strike me, mother with sons. This article originally appeared in tradition 9 1967, pp. Babylonian talmud tractate niddah 61a torah leadership. Norman lamm even observant religious people usually possess an element of doubt within their faith. Showing how honest questioning can lead to solid faith, conway encourages you to find an accepting community where you can voice your uncertainty, record your insights in a journal, and more.
Babylonian talmud tractate niddah 61a and the pit into which yishmael threw all the corpses of the people whom he had killed at the hand of gedalyah. Egypt, because every holiday is zekher lityetziat mitzrayim, in memory of the exodus from egypt. How can we affirm our jewish faith in a world so beset by doubt. In the end of faith, sam harris delivers a startling analysis of the clash between reason and religion in the modern world. Second day yom tov in the diaspora michael brochstein. The title of this book, in large, bold type on the jacket, encourages its potential readers to believe that they will be treated to a comprehensive investigation into the. I feel the same about this book, although this one reads more like bakkers sermons than the last book did. Accordingly, modern orthodox rabbis are often referred to as more moderate than their ultraorthodox counterparts, a term which seems to imply.
153 1289 1189 1177 547 897 302 321 1224 29 1429 283 1219 947 1016 18 1306 276 480 1385 27 1345 1200 309 782 643 487 964 1010 257 943 284 799 1230 497 55 317 1034 501 1428 690 402 223